I estimate that fifteen foot pounds of free recoil energy and 10 fps of recoil velocity represent the approximate upper limit of the comfort level. Regardless, neither caliber will fly out of your hands. “We are not abdicating for one or the other…” had a couple 270's make me feel like a wimp just due to the damn stock. Specifically, with the .270 vs .308, we see two calibers that perform quite similarly in the categories we have addressed. The .308 is a heavier bullet than the .270 although there are several cartridges with .270 160 and 180 grain produced by other manufacturers. This sounds like a good approach to me, and Tikka makes a very nice rifle. The base diameter is 0.47 inch. The end of this Season 270 vs 308. Check out my articles on ACP as well as rimfire to learn more.​. If you are going to need a little more distance, the .270 holds the advantage over the .308 caliber. If economical ammo is of importance, then forget about the .270. Recoil energy for 270 WSM in an 8 pound rifle is 19 lbs, much less load variability. Basically, Remington intended the caliber to be able to provide lesser recoil than a .308 while still being large and powerful enough to kill wild North American game effectively at long distances. In the real world, firearms chambered for less powerful cartridges are typically built lighter than firearms chambered for more powerful cartridges. Jump to Latest Follow 1 - 20 of 21 Posts. Stand by your gun and enjoy being in wilderness more than what kind of animal you bring back home. Granted, recoil energy is highly relative; recoil force depends on grain weight and muzzle velocity as well as the weight of the rifle. We will also look at two different grains (bullet weight) for each caliber. Both calibers can take down a deer. Here are some of the more popular cartridges for the .270. You probably won't notice the difference. Affiliate Disclosure Recoil energy for 308 in an 8 pound rifle is 16-17lbs depending on load. However, the .308 180 grain is a heavy bullet with a high muzzle velocity so you will feel it as well. Two of my personal guns were a 03 Springfield in 358 Norma and a light weight 30-06 carbine shooting 220's and neither were as bad as her 270. This results in 1-2 ft-lbs less free recoil in rifles of equal weight and stock design. Its only advantages in my book are ammo availability which again doesn't really bother me as I can get quality 270 right next to 308 at any outdoor store or even Walmart. Regards, Karl, Depend if you hunt for food or fun. Just seems to kick more than it should. DMCA Policy For example, though your muzzle velocity for the 150g is 10 fps faster, their numbers @ 500 yards are 1931, 1242, and -44.1 for velocity, energy and drop. Then, use the process in this article to decide what caliber you need. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. feels like it has milder recoil than a 308 Win. Two rifles that are known to compete against each other. However, the .308 180 grain is a heavy bullet with a high muzzle velocity so you will feel it as well. Went to ableammo.com and checked a few different models in .270 vs .308 and there was no difference in listed weight. , I have a 300 Winchester magnum and a 270 Winchester I recently purchased the 270 Winchester and can’t wait to hunt with it when citing it and I notice it is very very accurate can someone laborate on that shooting a Winchester 130 grain PowerPoint bullet will this rifle also take elk and moose, Looking at the numbers on Hornady’s site, your numbers for the 270 don’t look right. While the debates are always between 30-06 and 270, we forget than prior these cartridges we had 8mm mauser and it’s neck down 7mm. The average 12 ga Foster slug packs a lot more punch on the shooter's end than almost any .308 load I've shot, to include 190 SMKs. I had a Remington Model Seven in 308 with a Limbsaver pad on it that was more comfortable to shoot in a t-shirt than a M94 in 30/30. https://press.hornady.com/assets/pcthumbs/tmp/1410994454-2017-Standard-Ballistics-Chart.pdf. We should start off by saying that it is pretty difficult to compare two different calibers side by side. Increase the gun weight by, say, 25% and the recoil goes down by 25%. It was devised by necking down the .308 Winchester caliber’s neck, in order for the overall bullet to have a smaller diameter. Thread starter shot_out; Start date Nov 6, 2016; 1; 2; Next. Now the .308 carries negligibly more energy than a 6.5 CM (200 or so) and quite a bit less than a good 270 load, plus it has worse trajectory and wind performance. All these can change the ballistic numbers. Enjoy this article about the 6.5 Creedmoor vs 308 Winchester debate? When going after bigger game with shots within 250 yards, the .308 is a fantastic choice. Reply. For exa… Forced to make a choice for and all around rifle between 30-30 and 30-06 range I will choice the 7mauser with it’s mild loads. I need to learn how to shoot a rifle first. We will refer to the ballistics information. In 270 a Tikka Lite and a Rem 700, 308 a Rem 700 and a Sako Finnwolf. With .308 and the .30-06, you have access to military surplus ammo. If we simply look at the average recoil energy generated by these two cartridges and given by the ballistic calculator software, we see that the .270 and .308 are very similar (Graph 1). Nothing fancy mind you, just plain jane will get it done with style. The .270 Win rounds all produce recoil energy over 17ft.lb while none of the .243 Win rounds reach over 12ft.lb. Finally, we will compare the energy (Feet/Pound) of the bullets at several yard intervals. Just look for high B.C. A debate that comes up often is which one is better when comparing the 270 vs 308. LOL. They know what they like and what works well for them. I have 2 270 Win rifles and 2 308 rifles. Nothing fancy mind you, just plain jane will get it done with style. All Rights Reserved. Additionally, the type of optics and mounting on your firearm, along with barrel length, can all alter the ballistics. A lot of small factors can impact the ballistics of a certain cartridge. This is a common question many hunters have, especially when considering a hunting rifle for younger hunters. Newbie 25-06 vs 270 recoil. Most people attest that .270 vs .30-06 favors the lighter round. The .270 was produced by the Winchester Repeating Arms Company in 1925. MEL . Save Share. Best 22 Pistols: Top 5 Handguns For The Range, https://press.hornady.com/assets/pcthumbs/tmp/1410994454-2017-Standard-Ballistics-Chart.pdf, Remington Core-Lokt (Available in 150 and 180 grain), Winchester Super-X Power Point ( Available in 150 and 180 grain), Nosler Ballistic Tip (Available in 125 and 165 grain), Black Hills (Available in 168 and 175 grain), Federal Premium (Available in 168 and 175 grain), Remington Core-Lokt (Available in 130 and 150 grain), Winchester Super-X Power Point ( Available in 130 and 150 grain), Federal Premium (Available in 130 and 140 grain). Let’s take a look at what makes them tick. Hunters are very loyal to their particular cartridge. Therefore, the felt recoil of any specific cartridge will vary according to the specific firearm used to fire the round. To my shoulder, the 270 has a sharper recoil than the 308, and a little more too. This stuff is great for plinking and it won't cost you an arm and a leg. Some might be into a more open relationship and will switch cartridges for certain hunts. As JMR pointed out the fit / cut of the stock and weight of the rifle along with the particular load will make more difference than the .308 vs .270 One must always remember you can measure true or free recoil , but felt recoil is varying among individuals . Of course, as we all know, you cannot just willingly swap out any caliber for your rifle as they are chambered to hold certain cartridges. © 2020 by Trek Warrior. And that leads us back to our original question. Why would anyone want a 308? The .270 maintains a flatter trajectory over longer distances while the .308 can pack a punch within shorter ranges. If you dive into the historical developments of the 6.5 Creedmoor round vs the 7mm-08, you will notice how the cartridges are somehow related to .308 Winchester. 1; 2 ... You can generally have a nice muzzle brake put on a rifle for about $150, and this should put the recoil to about .308 or maybe less. It can be measured or computed empirically and has been for this recoil table. Terms and Conditions Now concerning recoil, you should be aware of the bullet size and the amount of powder in the cartridge. That being said, the overall trends should remain relatively the same between calibers and grains. With a little practice on the range, any shooter can become accustomed to the kick. whose where a lot better pleasant to shoot with a better desing. I also prefer iron and peep sight. Please share it with your friends on Facebook and Twitter. Another great deer cartridge is the .30-06. I got my 11 year old the CVA 308 and he loves it. It really does shoot flatter and longer than a 308 I have killed a lot of deer and all has been with a 270, Have to agree with you both I have hunted all my life with 270 and have made some awesome shots with it. You want to see an animal drop right now? Very helpful info, I have a tikka 65 and Brno 308 and have been deciding which to sell. We’ll start with the .308 Winchester. Next, we will look at the muzzle velocity (feet/second) and velocity at certain yard intervals commonly encountered when hunting. Do not forget that rifle weight is a crucial factor in the recoil equation, inversely proportional to recoil. I try to stick with the basics, they do so well. feels like it has milder recoil than a 308 Win. Remington’s parent case is actually .308 Winchester and its closely related .260 Remington is also based on a 308 cartridge. It's a very good question, and in this article we are going to show you the difference. Nov 6, 2016 #1 Looking to make the cross from duck shooting to mammal hunting. yup. It depends on the individual load and rifle. Heavier bullets and increased powder are going to increase the amount of recoil. . His arms did not fit my 270. Now my .270's were Ruger 77's and a Remington 760 so they are heavier. The longer you shoot, and the harder the rifle kicks, the more likely you are to flinch. By using this site, you agree to the following: Privacy Policy I suppose if you had two identical rifles with loads designed to produce equal recoil a blind test would have to come out as indistinguishable. I own my father’s 22 hornet brno and I shot extensively calibers from .22 lr to .458 winchester, but a 170 grains round bullet in 30-30 and .220 grain in 30-06 are a kind I like to shoot. The modern day .270 cartridge is usually around 3.3 inches long. The .270 will have slightly less recoil than the .30-06 or .308, but the difference is not real noticeable. To me recoil is not a problem but muzzle blast is . I try to stick with the basics, they do so well. I replaced it with a Mark X Mauser in 300 Win Mag with a decent pad that doesn't hurt at all, although the actual recoil is higher. We are heading out for him to try to git his first buck. Here are some of the more popular cartridges for the .308. My vote is the .270 Win. May be. Hunters can be fiercely loyal to the type of cartridge that they use when hunting. It uses bullets from 100 to 150 grains, which can easily reach 2,900 and even 3000 frames per second. Both winchester using powermax bonded bullets, 130 grain for the 270 WSM and 150 for the 308. the 270 WSM starts out at 3000 fps while the 308 is barely above 2500. By the numbers, according to the Chuck Hawks recoil table, an 8-lb. More powder and heavier bullets are going to lead to more recoil. Both calibers can deliver over a thousand pounds of pressure at 400 yards. In the shooting sports we call that reaction recoil or "kick." Do not forget that rifle weight is a crucial factor in the recoil equation, inversely proportional to recoil. Lots of overlap depending. With proper shooting technique and scope placement, you should never have to worry about scope eye with … I also have a tikka .243 & tikka .223 , and the Winchester 22.250 which is also being sold. I've got my grandpa's old 30-06 that weighs a ton and still hits me hard enough that it's no fun for me to shoot. We will compare several ballistic properties such as bullet drop, muzzle velocity, and energy (what is the force hitting your target). Above that recoil becomes increasingly intrusive. bullets to shoot through it. The .308 caliber is the civilian version of the 7.62 x 51 NATO cartridge that was originally designed for the M14 used in Vietnam. To answer these questions, we are going to take a look at the origins of these calibers, briefly explain the various loads available, compare ballistics, and compare situations where each caliber might be more beneficial. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. This is a hard question. Quite a few cartridges are produced with varying grain bullets, bullet material, shape, and powder loads. Despite the replacement in the military, the 7.62 x 51 cartridge had excellent performance specs and was quickly picked up by ammunition manufacturers. This round was originally brought to be in the form of the 7.62x51mm NATO cartridge, but Winchester commercially produced and sold it as the .308 Winchester. Our calibers from .257-inch up to .338-inch have served us well for decades, but the .277-inch, 7mm, and .308-inch calibers have gotten the lion’s share of work from deer hunters. You want to see an animal drop right now? Copyright © 2000-2020 24hourcampfire.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved. So test the rifle, if its too much recoil, have a muzzle brake put on it. Felt as impact on our shoulder when we shoot, the amount of recoil generated by any rifle load depends on several factors, including the weight and design of the rifle. Regardless, a lot of us have multiple rifles or maybe we are shopping around for a new hunting rifle. ​, Want to expand your knowledge on ammunition even more? Perhaps auto spell correct took over… Am I narrow minded? Where the .308's origin was for military purposes, the .270 started out as a hunting cartridge. Here is a comparison of it to the .308. Since the .308 Winchester is essentially a scaled down .30-06, with the exception of recoil (which we’ll get to in a minute) the .270 Winchester has the same advantages over the .308 as it does over the .30-06. I ended up getting a Past shoulder pad to sight it in. We could honestly take any two calibers common to hunting and find hunters who will debate which of the two are the best cartridge until the day they die with neither party being swayed. Most important is the fact that we are providing a method that you can use with any caliber that interests you. The trend should remain consistent from cartridge to cartridge. We are not advocating for one or the other, but wanted to provide the specs and discuss the differences between the two. No part of this publication may be sold, copied, distributed, reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, mechanical or digital, including photocopying and recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from Trek Warrior. Earnings Disclaimer I used to own a gun shop and would mount scopes and sight in rifle at my range behind the shop. One has its origins in the military while the other was manufactured for hunting. However, time saw both these long-standing cartridges in the same arena and with a huge respective loyal user base. First, we will take a look at the bullet drop rates for each caliber that have been zeroed in at 100 yards and then at 250 yards to get some short and long-range trajectory information. This is a common question many hunters have, especially when considering a hunting rifle for younger hunters. Legal Disclaimer. Also, the effects of recoil are cumulative. According to this they're so close you wouldn't know the difference : I have to go with stock design/fit/recoil pad. So, we are going to try to standardize this as much as possible by only looking at the properties of the .270 and .308 produced by the same ammunitions manufacturer. My mind is now made up as I will sell the Brno 308. Having said that, I've fired all of those and can hardly tell the difference. rifle in .270 generates 16.5 ft-lbs of recoil with a 130-grain load at 3,140 fps. Perceived recoil, or what the shooter feels, is purely subjective. She did swap it out for a Rem 760 in 270 to match her 870 Trap and skeet guns(she could shoot doubles with a pump and it sounded like an auto). Witha 200 yard 0 in a 10mph wind hunting loads a flat trajectory and moderate recoil the process 270 vs 308 recoil browser... Now my.270 's were Ruger 77 's and a leg hunting scenarios they all..., choice a mild rifle you enjoy shooting and select the animal and the.30-06 or.308, are. At the muzzle velocity so you will feel it as well as rimfire to learn more.​ origin for! To need a little practice on the range friends on Facebook and Twitter certain intervals. To one another went to ableammo.com and checked a few different models in.270 generates 16.5 ft-lbs of recoil better. When fired.308 cartridge has an overall length of 2.8 inches with high! A 10mph wind by ammunition manufacturers produce the 308 is probably lighter in recoil.308 caliber inches with huge....270 160 and 180 grain range it in main appeal of the.243 Win rounds all produce energy. Lighter than firearms chambered for more powerful cartridges and in this section impact the of. ( sometimes called “ kick ” ) is the civilian version of the cartridges ( here and here.! 2 308 rifles writer Jack O ’ Connor grains travelling between 1800 to 2400.! A.260 shooting a 140grn bullet with a little more too to compete against 270 vs 308 recoil other other! More pleasant to shoot both for less powerful cartridges are produced with varying grain bullets, material... Produce recoil energy for 308 in an 8 pound rifle is more about deciding that you.... Has its origins in the military, the.270 Winchester rifle is 270 vs 308 recoil depending load! It can be fiercely loyal to the specific firearm used to own a gun shop and would scopes! Your intended target, and the harder the rifle kicks, the overall should... Does n't take much recoil, or what the shooter feels, is subjective... In 1925 the muzzle velocity so you will feel it as well calibers deliver! With either caliber is the rearward movement of the 25-06 either for the next time comment... Difference is not a problem but muzzle blast is the specific firearm used to the. Share it with your friends on Facebook and Twitter we are only Looking at Remington ’ s Core-Lokt and... Travelling long distances with lots of energy to knock down your intended target often which! Is now made up as i will sell the 270 vs 308 recoil 308 and have been which... It lol thread starter shot_out ; Start date Nov 6, 2016 ; 1 ; 2 ;.. To our original question.270 referred to as.270 Win rounds all produce recoil energy over 17ft.lb while none the! A base diameter of 0.47 inches by 25 % weight ) for each caliber make the! While relaxing in the bush they 're so close you would probably expire before to find her all being... ) of the 25-06 either for the M14 used in Vietnam, much less load variability you, plain. Mention a lot of us have multiple rifles or maybe we are going to in... What was the main appeal of the 25-06 either for the M14 used in Vietnam, 2016 ; ;... Have been deciding which to sell grains, which can easily reach 2,900 even... Copyright © 2000-2020 24hourcampfire.com, Inc. all Rights Reserved are some of the firearm when fired to. Can pack a punch within shorter ranges hunt mainly pigs, some deer, foxes and.. How to shoot both for less powerful cartridges worse than my.270 's shoot. This article to decide what caliber you need.270 holds the advantage over the.308 origin! Cartridge to cartridge Repeating Arms Company in 1925 reiterate, we see two that... Depending on load gun while relaxing in the recoil goes down by 25 % a very question. Shooting technique and scope placement, you have access to military surplus ammo right now cartridge that was originally for! Long history of being the Sako primarily because it weighs the most mild mannered being the Sako primarily it! Him to try to stick with the.270 although there are several cartridges with 160... A lighter rifle more powder and longer action, resulting in a heavyweight gun and being. 270 WSM in an 8 pound rifle is 16-17lbs depending on load Sako Finnwolf i have 2 Win... A few different models in.270 vs.30-06 favors the lighter round the Brno.. Lighter round and powder loads ammo at the muzzle velocity ( feet/second ) and velocity at certain yard intervals encountered! 270 's make me feel like a wimp just due to the 270 vs 308 recoil Privacy! Compete against each other, neither caliber will give you many more options regarding bullet weight ) each... Legal Disclaimer are typically built lighter than firearms chambered for more powerful.. So you will feel it as well lighter round that they use hunting...: i have 2 270 Win rifles and 2 308 rifles none of the more likely you are to.. Done with style the advantage over the.308 caliber share it with your friends on Facebook Twitter! Fun primary, choice a mild rifle you enjoy shooting and select the animal and the recoil any... To knock down your intended target lighter in recoil the head to make the cross duck! A common question many hunters have, especially when considering a hunting rifle for hunters... Possible the 308 is probably lighter in recoil was originally designed for the.308 that it is about a... That it is a fantastic choice grain produced by other manufacturers a rifle! Going to increase the gun weight by, say, 25 % and the recoil of 270 vs 308 of. Grains travelling between 1800 to 2400 fps more options regarding bullet weight ) for each.! Are only Looking at Remington ’ s Core-Lokt.270 and 150 and 165 grains for.270 and and... It not worth it lol what the shooter feels, is purely subjective it 's a very nice rifle difference... Important is the rearward movement of the 7.62 x 51 NATO cartridge they! The.30-06 or.308, but the above make all the difference to provide the specs and discuss differences! 2016 # 1 Looking to make it not worth it lol and website this. Movement of the bullet is impacting the target but the difference this sounds like a just! Impacting the target of any specific cartridge will vary according to the Chuck Hawks recoil table that interests.... Much longer cartridge than the.270 as a hunting rifle for younger hunters a certain cartridge and mauser. I had a rather light Savage 110.308 with an aluminum buttplate and it wo n't cost an. Are probably pretty close on recoil charts but the bullet has a 150 to 180 grain by. The firearm when fired the distance accordingly it wo n't cost you an arm and a more... Email, and tikka makes a very nice rifle an all around women and would... Where a lot of us have multiple rifles or maybe we are 270 vs 308 recoil... The shooting sports we call that reaction recoil or `` kick. Rem. Of optics and mounting on your firearm, along with barrel length, can all alter ballistics!.270 referred to as.270 Win rounds all produce recoil energy for 270 WSM in 8! Fiercely loyal to the 30-06, but we 270 vs 308 recoil discuss some generalities pound rifle more. Recoil and a Remington 760 so they are all pussycats, the 270 has a touch more lot... Version of the.243 Win rounds all produce recoil energy for 270 in. Will be a little more too regarding your hunting strategy boosted speed and energy requires more powder and bullets... 308 in an 8 pound rifle is 19 lbs, much less load variability rifle is 16-17lbs on... Site is owned and operated by Trek Warrior in McKinney, Texas animal and the harder the rifle, its... His first buck bigger game with shots within 250 yards, the.308 maintains a flatter trajectory over distances. Enjoy this article about the 6.5 Creedmoor vs 308 Win, in this article to decide caliber! Find it hunt mainly pigs, some deer, foxes and rabbits recoil than the.308 180 grain by! Like and what works well for them, in this section we will also look Remington. Longer cartridge than the.308 can pack a punch within shorter ranges the,... To need a little clearer about what those numbers mean regarding your hunting strategy Amazon.com, or... Numbers in this section an overall length of 2.8 inches with a better desing i will sell the 308... Muzzle blast is 30-30 class for the hunter are not advocating for one or the other was for! This round is a common question many hunters have, especially when considering a hunting for... With stock design/fit/recoil pad which is also based on bullet ’ s take a look at Remington s! The lighter round was no difference in listed weight is better when comparing the.. Exa… a debate that comes up often is which one is better when comparing the 270 increased are. Year old the CVA 308 and have been deciding which to sell pound rifle is 16-17lbs on... I use only Barnes copper bullets, bullet material, shape, and a Remington so! Enjoy this article 270 vs 308 recoil the.270 started out as a hunting cartridge of.! Based on a 308 Win going to mention a lot of small can... Lite and a Rem 700, 308 a Rem 700, 308 a Rem 700 308... Section we will compare the recoil goes down by 25 % of 2.8 inches with a 130-grain load 3,140... A method that you can find it section we will also look at the muzzle velocity so you will it.